Due Diligence - The Institutional Manager Selection Process
By EC Assets Research Team, Manager Research · Published · Updated
Due Diligence: Due diligence is the systematic investigation of an investment opportunity before capital commitment. For alternative allocations, it splits into investment due diligence (strategy, performance, edge) and operational due diligence (controls, infrastructure, integrity).
What Due Diligence Is
Due diligence is the independent investigation of a manager or investment before committing capital and while it is held. In alternative investments it has two parts. Investment due diligence asks whether the strategy is sound, whether the manager has an edge that cannot be bought more cheaply and how risks are controlled. Operational due diligence asks whether the firm can be trusted with capital: who values the assets, who holds them, who checks the numbers and whether the people and controls are sound.
Both are needed. A strong strategy run by a firm with weak controls can lose money through error or fraud; a well-run firm without an edge will simply disappoint. Due diligence supports manager selection, but it is a separate discipline focused on verification.
How It Works
Investment due diligence starts with the track record, then tries to explain it. A factor decomposition regresses a fund's returns on common factors, such as the market and the size, value, profitability and investment factors of Fama and French (2015), to separate exposures an investor could buy cheaply through factor investing from what remains. Reviewers then examine process, capacity, risk limits, the team that produced the record and how the strategy behaved in stress. For hedge funds, they also test whether returns are suspiciously smooth: Getmansky, Lo and Makarov (2004) show that serial correlation in reported returns signals illiquid holdings or smoothed valuations.
Operational due diligence reviews the infrastructure that protects capital, covered in more detail under fund operations. It checks that an independent administrator calculates net asset value, that a recognised auditor audits the fund, that assets are held by independent custodians or prime brokers, that cash movements need several signatures, and that compliance, valuation policies and conflicts are documented and followed. Background checks cover principals and the firm. Brown, Goetzmann, Liang and Schwarz (2008) found that operational risk indicators disclosed in US hedge fund filings, such as conflicts of interest and past legal problems, predicted later fund failure.
Many large frauds failed basic checks. Madoff's funds used a tiny auditing firm and no independent administrator or custodian, and Bernard and Boyle (2009) showed that his reported returns could not have come from the options strategy he described.
Worked Example
Even a celebrated record looks different once factors are removed. Regressing Berkshire Hathaway's monthly returns on the Fama-French five factors gives:
| Period | Berkshire return | Market return | Alpha after five factors | Alpha t-statistic | R² |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1990 to 2007 | 16.78% | 10.66% | 4.83% | 1.06 | 0.32 |
| 2008 to 2025 | 9.74% | 11.13% | 2.39% | 0.73 | 0.46 |
| 1990 to 2025 | 13.21% | 10.90% | 3.81% | 1.38 | 0.37 |
Berkshire Hathaway class A shares (Yahoo Finance) against the Fama-French five factors and US market (Kenneth French data library); alpha annualised from monthly regressions.
Over 1990 to 2025 the shares returned 13.21 percent a year against 10.90 percent for the market. The regression shows a market beta of 0.74, a value loading of 0.54, a profitability loading of 0.24 and a size loading of -0.37: Berkshire held large, cheap, profitable companies, exposures an investor could partly replicate. The remaining alpha of 3.81 percent a year has a t-statistic of 1.38, short of the usual threshold of 2. Frazzini, Kabiller and Pedersen (2018) reach a similar conclusion with additional factors for low risk and quality, and show that modest leverage on those exposures explains much of Buffett's record.
The lesson for due diligence is not that Berkshire lacked skill, but that a return record alone, even over 36 years, cannot prove it. Reviewers must understand where returns come from and whether the sources will persist.
When It Applies (and Limitations)
Factor models are incomplete. Results depend on the factors chosen; omitted exposures such as low risk, quality or illiquidity can make skill look larger or smaller.
Short records. Most funds have far shorter histories than the example, so statistical tests are weaker still.
Private assets. For private equity and private credit, returns depend on appraisals and cash-flow timing, so decomposition relies on deal-level analysis.
Selection in the example. Berkshire is famous because it succeeded; when reviewers compare many managers, the best records are partly selected by luck, so a strong past result deserves scrutiny rather than automatic trust.
Checks can be gamed. Documents and references chosen by the manager show what the manager wants seen; independent verification matters most.
Why It Matters for Institutional Investors
Pay for skill, not exposure. Factor decomposition shows how much of a fee buys exposures available more cheaply.
Avoid avoidable losses. Operational checks address risks that no investment skill can offset, from fraud to failed processes.
Make it continuous. Ongoing monitoring of people, assets, service providers and controls catches changes after the initial review.
Document the decision. Written reports, red-flag lists and independent sign-off create accountability and help in later reviews, including those required under regulatory frameworks.
References
- Brown, S., Goetzmann, W., Liang, B., & Schwarz, C. (2008). Mandatory Disclosure and Operational Risk: Evidence from Hedge Fund Registration. Journal of Finance, 63(6), 2785-2815.
- Fama, E. F., & French, K. R. (2015). A Five-Factor Asset Pricing Model. Journal of Financial Economics, 116(1), 1-22.
- Frazzini, A., Kabiller, D., & Pedersen, L. H. (2018). Buffett's Alpha. Financial Analysts Journal, 74(4), 35-55.
- Getmansky, M., Lo, A. W., & Makarov, I. (2004). An Econometric Model of Serial Correlation and Illiquidity in Hedge Fund Returns. Journal of Financial Economics, 74(3), 529-609.
- Bernard, C., & Boyle, P. P. (2009). Mr. Madoff's Amazing Returns: An Analysis of the Split-Strike Conversion Strategy. Journal of Derivatives, 17(1), 62-76.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between investment and operational due diligence?
Investment due diligence asks whether the strategy makes sense, whether the manager has an edge and how risk is controlled. Operational due diligence asks whether the firm can be trusted with capital: who values the assets, who holds them, who audits them, how trades and cash move and whether the people and controls are sound.
What is a factor decomposition?
A regression of a fund's returns on common factors such as the market, size, value, profitability and investment. The coefficients show which exposures drive the returns, and the intercept, alpha, shows what is left. Investors can buy factor exposure cheaply, so only the alpha justifies active fees.
What are common operational red flags?
Self-administration or a related administrator, a small or unknown auditor, assets held without independent custody, unusually smooth returns, reluctance to give access to staff or documents, conflicts of interest, key-person dependence and a history of regulatory or legal problems.
Why do unusually smooth returns matter?
Because they may reflect illiquid assets valued with stale prices, deliberate smoothing or, in extreme cases, fabrication. Getmansky, Lo and Makarov (2004) show that serial correlation in reported returns signals illiquidity or smoothing, and Bernard and Boyle (2009) showed that Madoff's reported returns were inconsistent with his stated strategy.
Is due diligence finished once an investment is made?
No. Teams, assets, service providers, strategies and controls change, so investors monitor continuously and repeat operational reviews periodically, with special attention after key departures, rapid growth, changes in service providers or poor results.
Stay informed
Market commentary, firm news and research from EC Assets - direct to your inbox.