ESG Investing - Environmental, Social, Governance as Investment Lens

By EC Assets Research Team, Sustainable Investing · Published · Updated

ESG Investing: ESG investing incorporates environmental, social, and governance factors into investment decisions alongside traditional financial analysis. Practice ranges from negative screening to integrated risk analysis to impact-targeted strategies.

What ESG Investing Is

ESG investing takes environmental, social and governance factors into account alongside financial analysis. The label covers practices that differ a great deal:

Approach What it does Main aim
Exclusion Removes industries or companies, such as weapons, tobacco or coal Align holdings with values or policy
Best in class Keeps the highest-rated companies within each sector ESG tilt with sector balance
Integration Uses ESG information as one input to valuation and risk Better risk-adjusted returns
Thematic Invests in themes such as renewable energy or water Exposure to specific trends
Impact Targets measurable social or environmental outcomes Outcomes alongside returns

Most institutional programmes combine exclusions with integration; impact investing is most common in private markets, including infrastructure and private equity.

The modern form dates from the launch of the UN-supported Principles for Responsible Investment in 2006, which committed signatories to incorporate ESG issues into investment analysis and ownership.

How It Works

The evidence differs by approach. Friede, Busch and Bassen (2015) reviewed about 2,200 studies and found that roughly 90 percent reported a non-negative link between ESG and corporate financial performance, most of them positive. Governance has the longest record: Gompers, Ishii and Metrick (2003) found that US firms with stronger shareholder rights outperformed those with weaker rights by 8.5 percent a year in the 1990s, but Bebchuk, Cohen and Wang (2013) showed the gap disappeared in the 2000s as investors learned to price it.

Theory explains why evidence on returns is mixed. Pástor, Stambaugh and Taylor (2021) show that if investors like holding green assets, those assets should earn lower expected returns in equilibrium, yet they can still outperform for long periods when concern about climate rises unexpectedly. Realised returns can therefore point the opposite way from expected returns.

Measurement adds uncertainty. Berg, Kölbel and Rigobon (2022) found that ESG ratings from six major providers correlate only between 0.38 and 0.71, mostly because they measure the same attributes differently. A portfolio can be a leader on one provider's scores and average on another's.

Exclusions have a cost that can be measured directly: tracking error against the unrestricted market. For a constant excluded weight, tracking error equals that weight times the volatility of the gap between the excluded and the remaining stocks, so small exclusions of very different industries can matter more than large exclusions of similar ones.

Worked Example

Take the US stock market and remove the energy industry, covering oil, gas and coal, reweighting the rest by market value:

Period Market Market excluding energy Difference (points a year) Tracking error Average energy weight
1990 to 2007 10.76% 10.56% -0.20 1.04% 6.2%
2008 to 2020 10.40% 11.13% +0.73 1.25% 7.0%
2021 to 2022 0.27% -1.27% -1.54 0.95% 3.0%
2023 to August 2026 22.37% 22.78% +0.41 0.81% 3.3%
1990 to August 2026 11.14% 11.24% +0.10 1.10% 6.0%

Kenneth French 12 industry portfolios (CRSP), value-weighted returns with dividends, annualised; tracking error from monthly differences.

Over the whole period the exclusion changed returns by +0.10 percentage points a year at a tracking error of 1.1 percent: close to costless. The path was not. Energy was 12.1 percent of the market in July 2008, 1.6 percent in November 2020 and 3.0 percent in August 2026, and the exclusion cost 1.54 points a year in 2021 and 2022, when energy prices surged. A board that adopts an exclusion should expect years like these and decide in advance how much tracking error it accepts.

When It Applies (and Limitations)

Past returns are not expected returns. Periods in which ESG portfolios did well may reflect rising demand for them rather than a lasting premium.

Ratings disagree. With low agreement between providers, results depend on the data chosen, and scores often reward disclosure as much as performance.

Greenwashing. Labels can overstate what a product does. In 2023 the US SEC fined DWS 19 million dollars over misstatements about its ESG integration.

Rules are changing (status checked 15 October 2026). In the EU, the Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation has applied since March 2021; a revision under negotiation would replace the Article 8 and 9 classifications with Transition, ESG Basics and Sustainable categories, expected to apply around 2028 or later. In the US, the SEC's 2024 climate disclosure rule has been stayed since April 2024 and never took effect, and in May 2026 the SEC proposed rescinding it. In the UK, the FCA introduced an anti-greenwashing rule in May 2024 and sustainability labels from July 2024. The ISSB issued global sustainability disclosure standards in June 2023, which apply where national authorities adopt them.

Why It Matters for Institutional Investors

Define the purpose. Values alignment, risk management and impact need different tools and different measures of success; mixing them leads to policies that do none of them well.

Budget the tracking error. Exclusions and tilts change a portfolio's risk relative to its benchmark and should be set within the asset allocation and risk budget, with an eye on unintended factor exposures such as size or value.

Look behind the label. In manager selection, ask which data, ratings and exclusions a manager uses, how ESG affects actual decisions and how stewardship and voting are carried out.

Track the rules. Disclosure and labelling requirements differ by jurisdiction and are changing, so product classifications and reporting duties need regular review.

References

  1. Friede, G., Busch, T., & Bassen, A. (2015). ESG and Financial Performance: Aggregated Evidence from More than 2000 Empirical Studies. Journal of Sustainable Finance & Investment, 5(4), 210-233.
  2. Berg, F., Kölbel, J. F., & Rigobon, R. (2022). Aggregate Confusion: The Divergence of ESG Ratings. Review of Finance, 26(6), 1315-1344.
  3. Pástor, Ľ., Stambaugh, R. F., & Taylor, L. A. (2021). Sustainable Investing in Equilibrium. Journal of Financial Economics, 142(2), 550-571.
  4. Gompers, P., Ishii, J., & Metrick, A. (2003). Corporate Governance and Equity Prices. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 118(1), 107-155.
  5. Bebchuk, L. A., Cohen, A., & Wang, C. C. Y. (2013). Learning and the Disappearing Association between Governance and Stock Returns. Journal of Financial Economics, 108(2), 323-348.
  6. European Parliament and Council. (2019). Regulation (EU) 2019/2088 on Sustainability-Related Disclosures in the Financial Services Sector. Official Journal of the European Union.

Frequently asked questions

What is ESG investing?

Investing that takes environmental, social and governance factors into account alongside financial analysis. It includes excluding certain industries or companies, choosing the best performers within each sector, integrating ESG risks into valuation, investing in themes such as clean energy, and impact investing that targets measurable outcomes.

Does ESG investing reduce returns?

Not systematically. Friede, Busch and Bassen (2015), reviewing about 2,200 studies, found roughly 90 percent reported a non-negative link between ESG and corporate financial performance. Returns of specific approaches depend on the period: excluding energy helped in 2008 to 2020 and hurt in 2021 and 2022.

Why do ESG ratings differ between providers?

Because providers measure different things, weight them differently and measure the same thing in different ways. Berg, Kölbel and Rigobon (2022) found correlations between six major providers of 0.38 to 0.71, far below the near-perfect agreement of credit ratings.

What is greenwashing?

Overstating the environmental or social credentials of a product or firm. Regulators have acted against it: in 2023 the US SEC fined DWS 19 million dollars over misstatements about its ESG integration, and the UK FCA introduced an anti-greenwashing rule in May 2024.

What are SFDR Article 8 and Article 9 funds?

Under the EU Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation, applied since March 2021, Article 8 funds promote environmental or social characteristics and Article 9 funds have sustainable investment as their objective. As of October 2026 the EU is negotiating a revision that would replace them with Transition, ESG Basics and Sustainable categories.

Stay informed

Market commentary, firm news and research from EC Assets - direct to your inbox.