Hedging - Portfolio Protection Through Asymmetric Payoffs

By EC Assets Research Team, Risk Management · Published · Updated

Hedging: Hedging is the use of derivatives, short positions, or uncorrelated assets to offset specific risks in a portfolio. The institutional case is asymmetric protection, not zero-cost insurance.

What Hedging Is

Hedging means taking a position that offsets a specific risk in an existing portfolio. An equity investor can sell index futures to reduce market exposure, buy put options to limit losses below a level, or use currency forwards to remove exchange-rate risk on foreign holdings. The same trade is a hedge for an investor who owns the underlying exposure and a speculation for one who does not.

A hedge always has a cost. Futures hedges give up gains as well as losses. Options hedges keep the gains but charge a premium, which is usually more than the losses it is expected to cover, because investors pay to be protected.

How It Works

Futures hedges. The number of contracts needed is the portfolio's beta to the index times its value, divided by the value of one contract. Ederington (1979) showed that the hedge ratio which minimises variance is the correlation between position and hedge times the ratio of their volatilities; for a portfolio measured against its own index, this reduces to beta. What remains after the hedge is basis risk: the portfolio and the futures do not move exactly together.

Options hedges. Buying puts limits losses below the strike. The premium depends on the strike, the term and, above all, on implied volatility, which rises sharply when markets fall. Equity index puts are expensive on average: Bondarenko (2014) found that returns on S&P 500 puts were far more negative than standard models can explain, which is the volatility risk premium from the buyer's side. Put spreads, collars and longer-dated puts reduce the cost by giving up some protection or upside.

Currency hedges. Investors holding foreign assets often sell the foreign currency forward. Because forward rates reflect interest-rate differences, the hedge earns or costs roughly the gap between the two short-term rates each year: a US investor hedging euro assets back into dollars gains when dollar rates are above euro rates and pays when they are below.

Volatility hedges. Calls on the VIX pay when volatility jumps rather than when prices reach a level, which can complement puts in sudden sell-offs.

Worked Example

A 50 million dollar equity portfolio has a beta of 1.2 to the S&P 500. With the December E-mini future at 7,761.4 and a multiplier of 50 dollars, a full hedge needs 1.2 × 50,000,000 / (7,761.4 × 50) = 154.6 contracts, so about 155 contracts sold.

Protection with options instead depends on volatility. A 3-month put struck 5 percent below the index costs:

Implied volatility Premium, % of position Annualised, rolled quarterly
12% 0.50% 2.00%
18% 1.34% 5.36%
25% 2.50% 9.99%
35% 4.28% 17.10%

Black-Scholes with a 4.28 percent rate and 1.2 percent dividend yield; a single volatility for all strikes, so the skew, which makes out-of-the-money puts dearer, is ignored.

The long-run record of rolling protection comes from the Cboe S&P 500 5% Put Protection Index, which holds the index and buys monthly puts 5 percent out of the money:

1993 to October 2026 With monthly puts S&P 500 total return
Annual return 7.82% 10.96%
Volatility 13.5% 18.3%
Maximum drawdown -42.0% -55.3%
2008 -20.1% -37.0%
19 February to 23 March 2020 -11.8% -33.8%
2022 -19.8% -18.1%

Cboe PPUT index against the S&P 500 Total Return index (Yahoo Finance), common trading days 4 January 1993 to 14 October 2026.

Protection cost about 3.1 percentage points a year, so 1 dollar grew to 12.7 instead of 33.6. It halved the losses of the sudden crashes in 2008 and 2020 but did nothing in 2022, when the market fell steadily without a single month that pushed the puts deep into the money.

When It Applies (and Limitations)

Basis risk. A hedge on an index protects a portfolio only as far as the portfolio moves with that index; proxy hedges can fail exactly when needed.

Path dependence. Monthly puts protect against sharp falls within a month, not slow declines spread over many months.

Timing costs. Buying protection after volatility has risen locks in high premiums, which then decay as markets calm.

Liquidity and margin. Futures hedges require cash for daily margin, and over-the-counter hedges add counterparty exposure.

Modelling simplifications. The premium table ignores the volatility skew; actual out-of-the-money puts usually cost more.

Why It Matters for Institutional Investors

Hedge the losses that cannot be borne. Hedging pays when a loss would force an investor to sell, breach a funding requirement or abandon a strategy; it is a poor substitute for holding less risk otherwise.

Prefer rules to reactions. Programmes that buy protection on a schedule, or when volatility is low, avoid paying peak prices in a crisis.

Measure the drag. A long-run cost of about 3 percentage points a year for rolling equity puts is large; its benefit shows mostly in maximum drawdown, not in returns.

Test the payoff. Comparing structures in a payoff builder shows how spreads and collars trade cost against protection before committing capital.

References

  1. Hull, J. C. (2022). Options, Futures, and Other Derivatives (11th ed.). Pearson.
  2. Ederington, L. H. (1979). The Hedging Performance of the New Futures Markets. Journal of Finance, 34(1), 157-170.
  3. Bondarenko, O. (2014). Why Are Put Options So Expensive? Quarterly Journal of Finance, 4(3), 1450015.
  4. Israelov, R. (2019). Pathetic Protection: The Elusive Benefits of Protective Puts. Journal of Alternative Investments, 21(3), 6-33.

Frequently asked questions

What is hedging?

Taking a position that offsets a specific risk in an existing portfolio, such as selling index futures against an equity portfolio, buying put options, or using currency forwards against foreign holdings. A hedge reduces the risk targeted but usually costs money, either as a premium or as given-up gains.

What is the difference between hedging with futures and with options?

Futures remove exposure in both directions: losses are offset, but so are gains, at little direct cost. Options remove losses beyond the strike while keeping gains, at the price of a premium paid up front.

How much does put protection cost?

It depends on implied volatility and on how far out of the money the strike is. In the example in this entry, a 3-month put 5 percent out of the money costs 0.50 percent of the position at 12 percent volatility and 4.28 percent at 35 percent. Over 1993 to 2026, rolling monthly puts cost US equity investors about 3.1 percentage points of return a year.

Why do protective puts so often disappoint?

Because implied volatility usually exceeds the volatility that follows, so puts are expensive on average, and because they pay mainly in sudden, deep falls. In slow declines, such as 2022, monthly puts expire with little value while losses accumulate.

When should investors hedge?

When a loss would force them to change course, for example by breaching a funding level, a risk limit or a liquidity need. Protection bought when volatility is low costs much less than protection bought after markets have already fallen.

Stay informed

Market commentary, firm news and research from EC Assets - direct to your inbox.