Information Ratio - Sharpe Ratio for Benchmark-Relative Strategies
By EC Assets Research Team, Performance Analytics · Published · Updated
Information Ratio: The Information Ratio measures the consistency of excess returns relative to a benchmark. It is the active return divided by tracking error, and the benchmark-relative analog of the Sharpe ratio for active managers.
What the Information Ratio Measures
The information ratio asks how much return a manager earned above its benchmark for each unit of risk taken relative to that benchmark. The numerator is active return, the gap between portfolio and benchmark. The denominator is tracking error, the volatility of that gap. A manager who beats the index by 2 percent a year with 4 percent tracking error has an information ratio of 0.5.
It is the benchmark-relative sibling of the Sharpe ratio. Sharpe compares total return with cash and total volatility; the information ratio compares active return with active risk. For a manager hired to beat a stated index, only the second question matters: market risk the client could have bought cheaply through the index is not the manager's achievement.
The measure goes back to Treynor and Black's appraisal ratio of 1973, which divided alpha by residual risk. Richard Grinold's Fundamental Law of Active Management (1989) gave it its modern role as the central yardstick of active management.
How It Works
$$IR = \frac{\bar{R}_p - \bar{R}_b}{\sigma(R_p - R_b)}$$
Like Sharpe, it is computed from monthly differences and annualised by multiplying by √12. The Fundamental Law then explains where an information ratio comes from:
$$IR \approx TC \times IC \times \sqrt{BR}$$
| Component | Meaning | What drives it |
|---|---|---|
| IC, information coefficient | Correlation between forecasts and outcomes | Skill per decision |
| BR, breadth | Independent forecasts per year | Universe size and how often views genuinely change |
| TC, transfer coefficient | Share of the forecasts the portfolio actually expresses | Constraints such as long-only or position limits |
Breadth counts independent bets, not positions: 400 stocks that all load on the same factor are closer to one bet than to 400.
The transfer coefficient, added by Clarke, de Silva and Thorley (2002), explains why the same research produces a lower information ratio in a long-only fund than in an unconstrained one: a manager who cannot short can act on negative views only by underweighting, which is capped at the benchmark weight.
Worked Example
An equity manager beats the benchmark by 2.4 percent a year with 4 percent tracking error, an information ratio of 0.60. Two questions follow.
Is it skill? The t-statistic of the active return is roughly the IR times the square root of the number of years. After five years it is 0.6 × √5 = 1.34, short of the conventional threshold of 2. Reaching 2 at this IR takes (2 / 0.6)² = 11.1 years. A track record long enough to be convincing is usually longer than the patience of the committee reviewing it.
Where does it come from? Two ways to arrive at similar numbers:
| Discretionary stock picker | Systematic equity manager | |
|---|---|---|
| Information coefficient | 0.10 | 0.05 |
| Independent bets per year | 25 | 400 |
| Unconstrained IR (IC × √BR) | 0.50 | 1.00 |
| Transfer coefficient (long-only) | 1.0 | 0.6 |
| Realised IR | 0.50 | 0.60 |
The systematic manager needs only half the skill per decision; breadth does the rest, and the long-only constraint gives back much of the advantage.
The two profiles fail in different ways. A high-IC process depends on a few people and a durable edge. A high-breadth process depends on the independence of its bets and on capacity, because signals spread across hundreds of names erode as assets grow.
When It Applies (and Limitations)
The benchmark has to fit the strategy. A small-cap value manager measured against a large-cap index will show a high information ratio in years when small value outperforms, without any selection skill. Persistent factor exposure the benchmark omits shows up as apparent skill.
Ratios are comparable only within a category. A market-neutral fund with 4 percent active return on 5 percent tracking error has an IR of 0.80; a large-cap fund with 0.7 percent active return on 1 percent tracking error has 0.70. The numbers are close; the risks and the capacity behind them are not.
It needs time. As the worked example shows, even a strong IR takes a decade to separate from noise. Short windows mostly measure luck.
It is indifferent to scale but not to fees. Doubling active positions doubles both active return and tracking error and leaves the ratio unchanged; fees, by contrast, come straight off the numerator. A gross IR of 0.5 on 3 percent tracking error loses a third of its value to 50 basis points of fees.
Why It Matters for Institutional Investors
It is the currency of active-risk budgeting. In the mean-variance framework the optimal amount of active risk is proportional to the information ratio. A plan with a fixed active-risk budget should allocate it to the managers with the highest expected IR, not the highest past return.
It frames the choice between skill and breadth. Concentrated long/short equity and broad quantitative mandates can show the same IR for opposite reasons. Due diligence should test the component that carries the result: key-person and process risk for high IC, independence and capacity for high breadth.
It disciplines claims of outperformance. Translating an IR into the years needed to prove it tempers enthusiasm for three-year track records, and keeps attention on process quality, where the evidence actually is.
References
- Treynor, J. L., & Black, F. (1973). How to Use Security Analysis to Improve Portfolio Selection. Journal of Business, 46(1), 66-86.
- Grinold, R. C. (1989). The Fundamental Law of Active Management. Journal of Portfolio Management, 15(3), 30-37.
- Goodwin, T. H. (1998). The Information Ratio. Financial Analysts Journal, 54(4), 34-43.
- Clarke, R., de Silva, H., & Thorley, S. (2002). Portfolio Constraints and the Fundamental Law of Active Management. Financial Analysts Journal, 58(5), 48-66.
- Grinold, R. C., & Kahn, R. N. (2000). Active Portfolio Management (2nd ed.). McGraw-Hill.
Frequently asked questions
How is the information ratio different from the Sharpe ratio?
Sharpe measures return above cash per unit of total volatility. The information ratio measures return above a chosen benchmark per unit of tracking error, the volatility of the gap between portfolio and benchmark. For a manager hired to beat an index, the second is the relevant question.
What is tracking error?
The standard deviation of the difference between portfolio and benchmark returns, usually annualised from monthly data. An index fund runs a few basis points; a concentrated active equity fund can run 6 to 10 percent. It is the budget of active risk the manager spends.
What is a good information ratio?
Grinold and Kahn's often-quoted guide puts a top-quartile active manager at about 0.5 before fees, with 0.75 very good and 1.0 exceptional. Sustained figures well above 1.0 deserve a check for factor exposures the benchmark does not capture.
What is the Fundamental Law of Active Management?
Richard Grinold's 1989 result that the information ratio is approximately the information coefficient, the correlation between forecasts and outcomes, times the square root of breadth, the number of independent forecasts per year. Later work added the transfer coefficient for the share of forecasts that portfolio constraints let through.
How long does it take to prove an information ratio?
The t-statistic of the measured active return is roughly the IR times the square root of the number of years. Reaching a t-statistic of 2 therefore takes (2 / IR)² years: 16 years at an IR of 0.5, and still 4 years at an exceptional 1.0.
Stay informed
Market commentary, firm news and research from EC Assets - direct to your inbox.