Private Debt - Direct Lending, Mezzanine, and Distressed Credit
By EC Assets Research Team, Private Credit · Published · Updated
Private Debt: Private debt provides credit to companies and projects outside public bond markets. The category grew from $300B AUM in 2010 to over $1.5T by 2024 as banks retreated from middle-market lending.
What Private Debt Is
Private debt is lending that takes place outside public bond markets and broadly syndicated loans. A non-bank lender, usually a fund, negotiates a loan directly with a borrower and typically holds it to maturity. The main strategies are senior direct lending, unitranche loans that combine senior and junior debt in one facility, mezzanine debt, distressed debt, asset-based lending and debt secured on real estate and infrastructure.
The market grew after 2008 as bank regulation made lending to mid-sized, highly leveraged companies more expensive for banks. Most direct lending now finances companies owned by private equity funds, which value speed, confidentiality and certainty of terms. Block, Jang, Kaplan and Schulze (2024), surveying private debt fund managers, find that lenders focus on downside protection, rely on covenants and expect to be involved when borrowers run into trouble.
How It Works
Most direct loans are floating-rate: the coupon is a benchmark rate, now SOFR, plus a spread, often with a floor on the benchmark. Lenders also earn upfront fees and, if loans are repaid early, call protection. Their return is what remains after credit losses, which depend on how often borrowers default and how much is recovered.
Borrowers are riskier than the yields of public markets might suggest. Chernenko, Erel and Prilmeier (2022) find that US companies borrowing directly from non-banks are often unprofitable or highly leveraged, and that non-bank loans carry higher rates; banks lend more to such companies only when they can rely on positive earnings. The extra spread over public credit spreads pays for this risk, for illiquidity and for the cost of monitoring and working out loans.
Position in the capital structure decides recovery. Senior secured lenders are repaid first from the company's assets and from its value in a restructuring. Mezzanine lenders rank behind them and are paid higher coupons, often partly in additional debt rather than cash, sometimes with warrants for equity. Unitranche loans combine both in one facility, with a separate agreement among lenders dividing payments, which simplifies borrowing but can complicate restructurings.
Funds often add leverage of their own, borrowing against their loan portfolios to raise returns, which magnifies losses as well. In the EU, rules for funds that originate loans, including leverage limits, were added by AIFMD II, as described under regulatory frameworks.
Worked Example
A company with EBITDA of 50 borrows 250, five times EBITDA, at SOFR plus 5.75 percent with a 1 percent floor:
| Date | SOFR | Loan coupon | Annual interest | Interest coverage |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 31 December 2021 | 0.05% | 6.75% | 16.88 | 2.96x |
| 29 December 2023 | 5.38% | 11.13% | 27.82 | 1.80x |
| 14 October 2026 | 3.88% | 9.63% | 24.07 | 2.08x |
SOFR from the Federal Reserve Bank of New York; EBITDA held constant to isolate the effect of rates.
The lender's coupon rose from 6.75 to 11.13 percent without any change in the loan's value, the income gain that made direct lending attractive in 2022 and 2023. For the borrower, the same move meant its interest bill rose 65 percent and interest coverage fell from 2.96x to 1.80x, leaving far less room for a fall in earnings.
At today's SOFR, the lender's expected return depends on credit losses. With a 2 percent upfront fee spread over an expected loan life of three years, and assuming defaults of 2.5 percent a year with 40 percent of the loan lost in default, the expected return is about 9.63 + 0.67 - 1.00 = 9.30 percent a year. If defaults rise to 6 percent a year with half the loan lost, the expected return falls to 7.30 percent, before fund fees.
When It Applies (and Limitations)
Assumed loss rates. The default and recovery figures in the example are assumptions; actual experience depends on the cycle, the borrower and the lender's workout skill.
Limited history. The modern direct lending market has not yet been tested by a long, deep recession with high rates.
Valuations lag. Loans are valued by models and appraisals, so reported returns understate volatility and correlation with public credit.
Competition and terms. As more capital has entered the market, lenders have competed on price and terms, including fewer and looser covenants.
Fund structure. Fees, fund-level borrowing and the timing of calls and repayments separate investor returns from loan yields.
Why It Matters for Institutional Investors
Income with credit risk. Private debt offers high floating-rate income, but it is exposure to leveraged companies and should be judged alongside high-yield bonds and leveraged loans, not as a substitute for government bonds.
Underwriting and workouts. Differences between managers come from loan selection, covenant protection and recovery skill, which are best assessed through loss histories across a full cycle.
Look through leverage. Investors should know both the borrowers' leverage and any borrowing at fund level.
Plan for illiquidity. Closed-end funds lock capital for several years, and evergreen vehicles may limit or suspend redemptions in stress.
References
- Block, J., Jang, Y. S., Kaplan, S. N., & Schulze, A. (2024). A Survey of Private Debt Funds. Review of Corporate Finance Studies, 13(2), 335-383.
- Chernenko, S., Erel, I., & Prilmeier, R. (2022). Why Do Firms Borrow Directly from Nonbanks? Review of Financial Studies, 35(11), 4902-4947.
- Munday, S., Hu, W., True, T., & Zhang, J. (2018). Performance of Private Credit Funds: A First Look. Journal of Alternative Investments, 21(2), 31-51.
- Federal Reserve Bank of New York. (2026). Secured Overnight Financing Rate (SOFR) Data. Federal Reserve Bank of New York.
Frequently asked questions
What is private debt?
Loans made outside public bond and syndicated loan markets, negotiated directly between a borrower and a non-bank lender or small group of lenders. The main strategies are senior direct lending, unitranche loans that combine senior and junior debt, mezzanine debt, distressed debt, asset-based lending and real estate and infrastructure debt.
Who borrows from private debt funds?
Mostly mid-sized companies, many of them owned by private equity funds, that want speed, certainty and flexible terms, or that banks will not lend to. Chernenko, Erel and Prilmeier (2022) find that companies borrowing directly from non-banks are often unprofitable or highly leveraged.
Do floating rates protect lenders from rising interest rates?
They protect the lender's income but move the risk to the borrower. In the example in this entry, a borrower's interest bill rose 65 percent between the end of 2021 and the end of 2023, cutting interest coverage from 2.96x to 1.80x and making default more likely.
How are private debt returns measured?
Through the loan coupon and fees, minus credit losses, and, for funds, after management fees, incentive fees and any fund-level borrowing. Because loans are valued by models rather than market prices, reported volatility understates risk.
What are the main risks?
Default and recovery risk, which rise in recessions; concentration in leveraged, private-equity-owned companies; illiquidity; valuation lag; fund-level leverage; and covenant quality, which has loosened as competition among lenders has increased.
Stay informed
Market commentary, firm news and research from EC Assets - direct to your inbox.