Real Estate - Direct Property, REITs, and Real-Estate Debt

By EC Assets Research Team, Real Assets Research · Published · Updated

Real Estate: Real estate investment spans direct property ownership, listed REITs, and real-estate debt. Returns combine rental cash flows with capital appreciation; the asset class is structurally illiquid but inflation-linked.

What Real Estate Investing Is

Real estate investing provides exposure to land and buildings: apartments and houses, offices, shops, warehouses and specialised property such as hotels, data centres, healthcare and self-storage. Investors can own properties directly, invest through unlisted funds, buy shares of listed real estate investment trusts (REITs) or lend against property.

Sectors behave differently. Demand for offices has been reduced by hybrid working and shops compete with online retail, while warehouses benefited from e-commerce and data centres from cloud computing and artificial intelligence. Lease terms matter too: long fixed leases give stable income but little protection against inflation, while short leases, as in apartments and hotels, reprice quickly in both directions.

Returns come from rental income after operating costs, growth in that income, and changes in value. Over the long run the record is strong: Jordà and co-authors (2019) find that housing across 16 advanced economies earned real returns similar to equities from 1870 to 2015, with much lower volatility. Eichholtz and co-authors (2021) show that once maintenance, vacancies and other costs are counted properly, net rental yields are lower than headline figures suggest.

How It Works

The key relationship is between net operating income (NOI), rents after operating costs, and the capitalisation rate, or cap rate, the yield buyers require. Value equals NOI divided by the cap rate. Cap rates move with interest rates, risk premiums and expectations of rent growth, so values can fall when rates rise even if rents are growing.

Most property is financed partly with debt, which magnifies returns. When values fall, the equity absorbs the whole loss; lenders, including private debt funds, sit in front of it. Strategies are grouped by risk: core strategies buy stable, well-let properties with moderate leverage; value-add and opportunistic strategies take on leasing, renovation or development risk with more debt.

Real estate debt offers a different position in the same assets. Senior mortgages at moderate loan-to-value ratios are protected by the equity beneath them, while mezzanine loans sit closer to the equity and earn more. As banks reduced commercial property lending after 2022, non-bank lenders took a larger share of the market.

Measurement differs by route. REITs are priced every day and move with the stock market. Unlisted funds report appraised values, which adjust slowly: Geltner (1993) showed that appraisals smooth and lag market prices, so unlisted property appears less volatile and less correlated with equities than it really is.

Worked Example

A property earns NOI of 5.00 and is bought at a 4.5 percent cap rate, a value of 5.00 / 0.045 = 111.11. Over two years, rents grow 2 percent a year, but interest rates rise and buyers now require a 6.0 percent cap rate. The value becomes 5.202 / 0.060 = 86.70, a fall of 22.0 percent, despite higher income.

If the purchase was financed with 55 percent debt, 61.11, the owner's equity falls from 50.00 to 25.59, a loss of 48.8 percent before rental income, which in two years would offset only a small part.

Listed REITs show how this works in markets:

US listed REITs and US equities REITs (VNQ) S&P 500 total return
2022 return -26.3% -18.1%
Volatility, 2005 to 2025 21.7% 14.8%

Yahoo Finance adjusted closes for the Vanguard Real Estate ETF and the S&P 500 Total Return index; volatility from monthly returns.

REITs fell 73.1 percent from February 2007 to March 2009 and 34.5 percent from December 2021 to October 2023, as interest rates rose. Over 2005 to 2025 they had a monthly correlation of 0.74 with US equities. Unlisted property values over the same periods typically fell less and later, reflecting appraisal smoothing more than lower risk.

When It Applies (and Limitations)

Simplified valuation. The example uses a single cap rate and ignores capital spending, lease expiries and transaction costs, which in practice matter a great deal.

Sector and location dominate. Offices, shops, warehouses and apartments have followed very different paths, and local markets differ even more.

REITs are not pure property. Listed prices also reflect stock market sentiment, management and the REITs' own borrowing.

Appraisals lag. Unlisted returns understate volatility, so comparing them directly with listed assets flatters property.

Costs and illiquidity. Buying and selling property takes months and costs several percent of value, which long holding periods are needed to recover.

Why It Matters for Institutional Investors

Rate sensitivity. Property is long-duration exposure; the asset allocation should treat it as sensitive to real interest rates, like infrastructure.

Leverage discipline. Loan-to-value ratios, debt maturities and covenants determine whether a fall in values becomes a forced sale.

Measure honestly. Adjusting unlisted returns for smoothing, or comparing them with listed equivalents, gives a truer picture of risk and correlation.

Choose the route. REITs offer liquidity and diversification at the cost of equity-like volatility; unlisted funds and direct holdings offer control and income at the cost of illiquidity and lagging valuations.

References

  1. Jordà, Ò., Knoll, K., Kuvshinov, D., Schularick, M., & Taylor, A. M. (2019). The Rate of Return on Everything, 1870-2015. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 134(3), 1225-1298.
  2. Geltner, D. (1993). Estimating Market Values from Appraised Values without Assuming an Efficient Market. Journal of Real Estate Research, 8(3), 325-345.
  3. Eichholtz, P., Korevaar, M., Lindenthal, T., & Tallec, R. (2021). The Total Return and Risk to Residential Real Estate. Review of Financial Studies, 34(8), 3608-3646.
  4. Geltner, D., Miller, N., Clayton, J., & Eichholtz, P. (2013). Commercial Real Estate Analysis and Investments (3rd ed.). OnCourse Learning.

Frequently asked questions

How do investors gain exposure to real estate?

Through direct ownership of properties, unlisted funds, listed real estate investment trusts (REITs), and real estate debt such as commercial mortgages and mezzanine loans. Each route differs in liquidity, control, costs and how often values are measured.

What is a capitalisation rate?

The ratio of a property's net operating income to its value, similar to an earnings yield. Cap rates tend to rise with interest rates and risk premiums; because value equals income divided by the cap rate, a rise from 4.5 to 6.0 percent cuts value by a quarter for unchanged income.

Why do REITs and unlisted property funds report different returns?

Because REIT prices reflect the market every day, while unlisted values come from periodic appraisals that adjust slowly. Geltner (1993) showed how appraisal-based values smooth and lag true market values, making unlisted property look less volatile and less correlated with equities than it is.

Does real estate hedge inflation?

Partly. Rents on short leases or leases indexed to inflation can rise with prices, but higher inflation often brings higher interest rates and cap rates, which lower values. Over long periods, Jordà and co-authors (2019) find real returns on housing comparable to equities.

What are core, value-add and opportunistic strategies?

Labels for risk. Core strategies buy stable, well-let properties with modest leverage; value-add strategies improve or re-let properties; opportunistic strategies take on development, distress or major repositioning, usually with more leverage and higher target returns.

Stay informed

Market commentary, firm news and research from EC Assets - direct to your inbox.