A Two Trillion Dollar Valuation Is Not the Same as a Two Trillion Dollar Business
By EC Assets · Published · Updated
A valuation is a claim about the future. A business is cash that exists in the present.
The two are easy to confuse, and rarely is the gap between them as visible as it has been this month.
SpaceX completed the largest listing in history. The shares were priced at $135, valuing the company at around $1.77 trillion. On the first day of trading they closed near $161, up almost a fifth, lifting the market value above $2 trillion. Within days the company returned to the market for a further $25 billion in bonds, an offering that drew close to $90 billion in orders.
Striking numbers. They measure appetite, not earnings.
The company produced roughly $18.7 billion in revenue last year and lost close to $5 billion doing so. Its accumulated deficit since founding runs past $40 billion. The valuation does not rest on those figures. It rests on what the next two decades are assumed to deliver.
The analysts covering the stock cannot agree on the size of that assumption. One opened with a sell rating and a target well below the offer price. Another puts fair value at less than half of where the shares trade. A third can justify the price, but only by looking out twenty to twenty-five years.
That disagreement is the whole story. A number this large is not a measurement. It is a forecast wearing the clothes of a fact.
When price separates this far from present cash flow, a security stops describing a business and starts describing belief. And belief reprices faster than revenue ever can.
This is why we are cautious about building positions around a narrative. At EC Assets, the aim is to construct return streams that do not depend on whether a particular story comes true.
Conviction can be right and still be early. It can be early and never recover.
A market can assign any number it likes to a future. The future is under no obligation to honour it.
Stay informed
Market commentary, firm news and research from EC Assets - direct to your inbox.