Leverage - Borrowing to Amplify Investment Exposure

By EC Assets Research Team, Risk Strategy · Published · Updated

Leverage: Leverage is the use of borrowed capital to increase investment exposure. It amplifies both returns and losses, fundamentally changes risk profiles, and is the single most common cause of catastrophic losses in institutional investing.

What Leverage Is

Leverage is exposure larger than the capital that supports it. A portfolio with 100 million of equity that holds 200 million of assets, financed by 100 million of borrowing, runs two times leverage. The same effect can be created without borrowing at all: a futures contract, a total return swap or an option gives exposure to a notional amount far larger than the cash posted against it.

Leverage multiplies returns, and it multiplies them in both directions. What makes it dangerous is not the multiplication but its interaction with compounding, financing and the right of lenders to demand collateral when prices fall. Almost every large institutional failure of the past three decades combined a reasonable-looking strategy with more leverage than its worst month could carry.

How It Works

With leverage L, an underlying return R and a financing rate r on the borrowed part:

$$R_{\text{levered}} = L \times R - (L - 1) \times r$$

Equity disappears when the underlying falls by 1/L: 50 percent at two times, 20 percent at five, 4 percent at 25. Three measures describe a book, and each answers a different question:

Measure Definition What it captures
Gross leverage (Longs + shorts) / equity Balance-sheet size, financing need, counterparty exposure
Net leverage (Longs - shorts) / equity Directional market exposure
Notional leverage Sum of derivative notionals / equity Exposure hidden in futures, swaps and options

A market-neutral fund holding 300 million long and 300 million short on 100 million of equity runs six times gross and zero net; both numbers are true and neither is the whole story.

Leverage also scales volatility: two times leverage doubles volatility and quadruples variance. That last fact drives the most counter-intuitive result in the subject.

Worked Example

An asset earns 8 percent a year on average with 15 percent volatility; borrowing costs 5 percent. The compounded return is roughly the average return minus half the variance:

Leverage Average return Volatility Compounded return (approx.)
1× 8.0% 15% 6.9%
2× 11.0% 30% 6.5%
3× 14.0% 45% 3.9%

More leverage raises the average return and lowers the compounded one beyond about 1.3 times.

At two times leverage the average return is 2 × 8 - 1 × 5 = 11 percent, but half the variance is 0.30² / 2 = 4.5 percent, leaving about 6.5 percent compounded, less than the unlevered asset. The ratio that maximises compounded growth is the Kelly fraction (8 - 5) / 15² = 1.33. Beyond it every extra unit of leverage adds risk and subtracts growth: this is volatility drag multiplied by the square of the leverage.

The recovery arithmetic shows why the order of events matters. A 20 percent fall in the underlying costs an unlevered investor 20 percent, recovered with a 25 percent gain. At two times the equity falls 40 percent and needs 67 percent to recover; at four times it falls 80 percent and needs 400 percent. The drawdown calculator shows how quickly the required gain explodes.

When It Applies (and Limitations)

Leverage ratios are not comparable across assets. Five times leverage on short-dated government bonds can carry less risk than one times on a single equity, because the underlying volatility differs by an order of magnitude. Risk is leverage times volatility, not leverage alone.

Financing is not guaranteed. Lenders can raise haircuts or withdraw lines when markets fall, which is exactly when the borrower can least afford it. Brunnermeier and Pedersen (2009) showed how falling prices, rising margins and forced sales reinforce each other in a spiral in which funding liquidity and market liquidity collapse together.

Daily-reset products decay. A three-times leveraged ETF resets every day. If the index rises 10 percent and returns to its start twice, the fund goes 100, 130, 94.55, 122.91, 89.39: down about 11 percent with the index flat. Leveraged ETFs are built for short holding periods.

Leverage can be hidden. Total return swaps spread across several prime brokers let Archegos Capital build exposure that no single lender could see in full; when its concentrated positions fell in March 2021 the unwind cost its banks around 10 billion dollars.

Why It Matters for Institutional Investors

Most catastrophic losses run through it. Long-Term Capital Management ran balance-sheet leverage of roughly 25 to 30 times on relative-value trades and needed a 3.6 billion dollar recapitalisation by a group of banks, brokered by the New York Fed, in 1998. Lehman Brothers entered 2008 with leverage of about 30 times; a 3 to 4 percent fall in asset values was enough to erase its equity.

Regulation now caps or discloses it. Basel III requires banks to hold Tier 1 capital of at least 3 percent of total exposure, which caps leverage at about 33 times. The EU's AIFMD and the US Form PF require alternative fund managers to report gross and commitment leverage to supervisors.

Due diligence must look past the headline. Ask for gross, net and notional figures, financing terms, margin arrangements and the number of counterparties. A manager's leverage is only as stable as its least patient lender.

Moderate leverage can be efficient. Levering a low-volatility, diversified portfolio can achieve a target return with less concentration than holding riskier assets unlevered, the logic behind risk parity. The case rests on stable financing and on staying well below the growth-maximising ratio.

References

  1. Ang, A., Gorovyy, S., & van Inwegen, G. B. (2011). Hedge Fund Leverage. Journal of Financial Economics, 102(1), 102-126.
  2. Brunnermeier, M. K., & Pedersen, L. H. (2009). Market Liquidity and Funding Liquidity. Review of Financial Studies, 22(6), 2201-2238.
  3. Geanakoplos, J. (2010). The Leverage Cycle. NBER Macroeconomics Annual, 24, 1-65.
  4. Cheng, M., & Madhavan, A. (2009). The Dynamics of Leveraged and Inverse Exchange-Traded Funds. Journal of Investment Management, 7(4), 43-62.
  5. Basel Committee on Banking Supervision. (2014). Basel III Leverage Ratio Framework and Disclosure Requirements. Bank for International Settlements.

Frequently asked questions

Why is leverage dangerous if it amplifies gains and losses equally?

Because losses compound against a smaller base. At two times leverage a 25 percent fall in the underlying halves the equity, and recovering from a 50 percent loss takes a 100 percent gain. At high enough leverage the equity is gone before any recovery can begin.

What is the difference between gross and net leverage?

Gross leverage adds longs and shorts: 100 million long and 100 million short on 50 million of capital is four times gross. Net leverage subtracts them: the same book is zero net. Gross measures balance-sheet size, financing need and counterparty exposure; net measures the directional market bet.

How much leverage do hedge funds use?

Less than headlines suggest on average, and much more in some strategies. Ang, Gorovyy and van Inwegen (2011) found average gross leverage of about two times in their sample, with relative-value strategies, which earn thin spreads, running the most.

Is a futures position leverage?

Yes. A futures contract gives full notional exposure for an initial margin that is typically a small fraction of it. The leverage does not appear as borrowing on the balance sheet, which is why notional exposure, not cash borrowed, is the measure that matters.

Why do leveraged ETFs lose value in sideways markets?

They reset to their target multiple every day. After a rise and an equal-percentage fall the fund is below where a fixed exposure would be, and the gap grows with volatility. Over two round trips of plus 10 and back, a three-times daily fund loses about 11 percent while the index ends flat.

Stay informed

Market commentary, firm news and research from EC Assets - direct to your inbox.