Managed Futures (CTA) - Systematic Trend-Following and Crisis Alpha

By EC Assets Research Team, Alternatives Research · Published · Updated

Managed Futures: Managed futures, run by CTAs, systematically trades a diversified basket of liquid futures - mostly via trend-following: buy what is rising, sell what is falling, sized by volatility. Its positively-skewed, long-volatility return profile makes money in sustained trends and crises, earning the label 'crisis alpha'.

What Managed Futures Are

Managed futures funds, run by commodity trading advisors, trade a diversified set of liquid futures and forwards across equity indices, government bonds, currencies and commodities, usually with systematic rules rather than discretion. Most of the industry's assets follow some form of trend following: buying markets that have been rising and selling those that have been falling.

The case for them rests on the shape of their returns rather than their average level. Trend-following strategies have tended to perform well in prolonged market declines, when traditional portfolios suffer, which is why they are often described as providing crisis alpha.

How It Works

The classic signal is time-series momentum: the sign of a market's return over the past 6 to 12 months. Moskowitz, Ooi and Pedersen (2012) found that a market's own past 12-month return predicts its next month's return across 58 liquid futures and forwards, and Hurst, Ooi and Pedersen (2017) extended the evidence to more than a century of data.

Each position is sized inversely to the market's recent volatility, so that a bond future and a crude oil future contribute similar risk, and the whole portfolio is scaled to a volatility target, the same idea described under volatility targeting:

$$w_i = \text{sign}\left(r_i^{,12m}\right) \times \frac{\sigma_{\text{target}}}{\hat\sigma_i}$$

Because positions follow prices up and down, trend following behaves somewhat like a long straddle: it tends to gain from large moves in either direction and to lose small amounts in markets that move sideways. Fung and Hsieh (2001) showed that trend-following fund returns resemble those of lookback straddles. Trading takes place in exchange-listed futures, so positions are liquid and can be valued daily. A futures position needs only a margin deposit, typically a small fraction of its notional value, so most of a fund's assets sit in short-term government bills. Investors therefore earn the futures gains or losses plus the interest on that collateral.

Trend following is the core, but many programmes add other systematic signals, such as carry, which favours markets with high roll yield or interest rates, short-term pattern models and cross-sectional momentum across markets. These spread the sources of return but also blur the crisis profile that pure trend following offers.

Worked Example

A simple four-market version, using the S&P 500, an approximate 10-year Treasury, EUR/USD and USD/JPY from February 2006 to October 2026, rebalances monthly on the sign of each market's 12-month return with volatility-scaled positions:

Year Trend test S&P 500
2008 +9.1% -38.5%
2009 -11.3% +23.5%
2022 +17.4% -19.4%

Price returns only, without cash interest, carry, financing or costs; a professional programme trades dozens of markets.

Over the whole period the test returned 1.7 percent a year with volatility of 9.31 percent and a monthly correlation with the S&P 500 of 0.12. The pattern is the point rather than the level: it gained in the long declines of 2008 and 2022, as falling equities and, in 2022, falling bonds formed trends, and lost in 2009, when markets reversed abruptly. Its return level is understated because futures investors also earn interest on the cash held as margin.

When It Applies (and Limitations)

Whipsaw. In trendless, choppy markets, signals flip often and the strategy repeatedly buys after rises and sells after falls.

Sharp reversals. A V-shaped recovery, as in 2009, catches trend followers positioned for the old trend.

Long flat periods. Trend-following returns were weak for much of the 2010s, when central bank policy suppressed volatility and trends were short-lived. Investors who judged the strategy on those years often exited before 2022.

Design choices matter. The lookback period, the set of markets and the speed of signals change results materially. Faster models react sooner to a new trend but trade more and suffer more whipsaw; slower models hold trends longer but give back more at reversals.

Costs and capacity. Fees, often 2 and 20 historically, and trading costs absorb a large share of gross returns; signals are also widely known, which raises the risk of crowding.

Why It Matters for Institutional Investors

A diversifier with crisis behaviour. Low average correlation with equities and a tendency to gain in prolonged declines make trend following one of the few liquid strategies that has helped portfolios in bad years. Its return distribution has less negative skewness than equities.

Liquidity and transparency. Exchange-traded futures can be valued and exited daily, and rules can be explained, unlike many hedge funds with illiquid holdings.

Complement to discretionary macro. Systematic trend following and discretionary global macro trade similar markets with different methods, and their returns are only partly related.

Sizing for its purpose. Because its value shows up mostly in bad years, a trend allocation has to be large enough to matter in a crisis, often several percent of a portfolio, and judged over full cycles rather than single years.

Behavioural test. The hardest part is holding the strategy through years of small losses so that it is still there when a crisis arrives.

References

  1. Moskowitz, T. J., Ooi, Y. H., & Pedersen, L. H. (2012). Time Series Momentum. Journal of Financial Economics, 104(2), 228-250.
  2. Hurst, B., Ooi, Y. H., & Pedersen, L. H. (2017). A Century of Evidence on Trend-Following Investing. Journal of Portfolio Management, 44(1), 15-29.
  3. Fung, W., & Hsieh, D. A. (2001). The Risk in Hedge Fund Strategies: Theory and Evidence from Trend Followers. Review of Financial Studies, 14(2), 313-341.
  4. Kaminski, K. M., & Greyserman, A. (2014). Trend Following with Managed Futures: The Search for Crisis Alpha. Wiley.

Frequently asked questions

What are managed futures?

Funds run by commodity trading advisors that trade liquid futures and forwards across equities, bonds, currencies and commodities, usually with systematic rules. Most of the assets follow some form of trend following, going long rising markets and short falling ones.

Why is trend following called crisis alpha?

Because prolonged crises tend to produce trends: equities fall for months, government bonds often rally, currencies and commodities move. Trend-following models adapt to those moves and have historically gained in several major equity declines, including 2008 and 2022.

When does trend following lose money?

In choppy, trendless markets, where signals repeatedly flip and the strategy buys high and sells low, and in sharp reversals, where it is positioned for the old trend when the market turns. In the test in this entry, 2009 was the worst year because markets rebounded abruptly after the 2008 crash.

How are positions sized?

Usually inversely to volatility, so that each market contributes a similar amount of risk, with the whole portfolio scaled to a volatility target. That lets a single fund trade bond futures and crude oil futures in the same risk units.

What evidence supports trend following?

Moskowitz, Ooi and Pedersen (2012) document time-series momentum across 58 futures and forward markets, and Hurst, Ooi and Pedersen (2017) extend the evidence back more than a century. Returns vary greatly between decades, and costs and fees reduce what investors receive.

Stay informed

Market commentary, firm news and research from EC Assets - direct to your inbox.